Skip to main content

The Truth About BTO Coffeeshop Rentals, Can Rental Price Be Lowered?

 






Have you ever wondered why hawker food prices keep rising? Why your simple chicken rice now costs $5 or more? Many hawkers are struggling, not because they want to raise prices, but because of high food costs, rental fees, and labor expenses. Today, I’m going to focus on rental costs—one of the biggest reasons why food prices are going up.

Before becoming a content creator, I was aspired to be a hawker. I even tried bidding for a hawker stall but lost. Over the years, I’ve spoken to many hawkers about their struggles, and today, I want to share insights that I believe many hawkers want the government to hear.

You might ask, what have coffeeshop have to do with the government? Well, new BTO coffeeshop are awarded by bidding system from HDB. BTO coffeeshops are charging sky-high rental fees. For example, a new coffeeshop in Tampines has stalls renting for $8,000 to $10,000 per month! Another coffeeshop in Tengah was awarded at $60,000 per month, meaning each stall’s rental is at least $8,000. Good luck to the Tengah resident on finding affordable food. 

From my research, HDB awarded 9 new BTO coffeeshops in 2024. The highest rental awarded was $89,000 per month, while the average was around $59,000 per month. If a coffeeshop has 10 stalls, and the coffeeshop operator make a profit of $2,000 per stall, each stall’s rental would still be $8,000 per month or $263 per day!

HDB requires new BTO coffeeshops to sell budget meals at $3.50, but let’s do the math.

Even if hawkers make 100% profit on every meal, they need to sell at least 150 budget meals daily just to cover rent. But in reality, food costs, labor, electricity, and other expenses exist, so hawkers are not making much for $3.50 meals and required 200-300 budget meals just to break even. They have to sell regular dishes at average $5 and above in order to breakeven or making a profit if sales is good.

So before you complain about your $5 chicken rice, remember—a huge chunk of that money is going to cover rental costs, not just ingredients.

Only recently, the government said they will consider other factors beyond just the highest bid when awarding coffeeshop tenders. But I believe the simplest solution is to cap coffeeshop rental at $20,000 per month.

With lower rental, hawkers can rent stalls at below $3,000 per month, which would bring down food prices. Yes, the government might lose afew hundreds of millions per year, but in return, Singaporeans get more affordable food, and hawkers won’t be forced out of business.

At the end of the day, I’m not an economist or an analyst—I’m just a Singaporean giving honest feedback. If we don’t address this issue, hawkers will continue to struggle, and affordable food might become a thing of the past. I do hope the government representative can go around and talk to stalls owners to understand the people better?

What do you think? Should the government step in to lower rental costs? Let me know in the comments!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

New Punggol Northshore BTO Plagued by Water Seepage and Electrical Hazards

  ***Update: HDB, Maincon and Consultant has came down to the unit to check. Will update on status once we have more information. A Punggol Northshore BTO homeowner, who moved into his newly renovated flat in July 2024, has voiced frustration over severe water leakage issues that have left his unit unsafe and unlivable. Water has been observed seeping from an electrical powerpoint, with puddles forming on the floor and walls showing bubbling and signs of damage from moisture. The source of the leak appears to be an external wall adjacent to the master bedroom, according to assessments by the main contractor. However, the leakage has already caused significant damage to the flat's walls and paintwork, leaving the homeowner distressed. Adding to the frustration, the main contractor advised the homeowner to avoid using the affected power switches in the living room and bedroom due to the risk of a short circuit. Despite the warning, the homeowner has no choice but to turn on the light...

The Gateway to Singapore’s Digital Future, Punggol Coast MRT Station Opens Today!

  The Punggol Coast MRT station, the 17th station on the North East Line (NEL), officially opened on December 10, 2024. Located in the heart of the Punggol Digital District (PDD), it extends the NEL’s total length to 22 km and enhances accessibility for over 200,000 households within a 10-minute walk of an NEL station. Senior Minister Teo Chee Hean, speaking at the launch, emphasized the station's role in transforming Punggol Town into a vibrant, connected, and sustainable hub. Travel time for Punggol North residents to Outram Park is now reduced to 45 minutes, down from 60 minutes. Transport Minister Chee Hong Tat highlighted the foresight in planning Singapore’s transport infrastructure, such as provisions made two decades ago for the Cross Island Line interchange at Punggol MRT station. This long-term approach underscores Singapore’s commitment to future generations. The station integrates seamlessly with PDD, a 50-hectare smart and sustainable district focusing on digital indus...

Crackdown on Illegal Ride-Hailing with 4 Drivers Caught in LTA Operation

  In a recent operation conducted by the Land Transport Authority (LTA) of Singapore, four drivers were caught and had their vehicles impounded for providing illegal ride-hailing services. These unauthorized services operated both within Singapore and across the border to Malaysia, posing significant risks to passengers. The LTA has issued a stern warning to the public, advising against using such illegal services due to the lack of proper licensing and insurance, which can leave passengers vulnerable in the event of accidents. The operation underscores LTA’s commitment to ensuring the safety and regulation of ride-hailing services in Singapore. Drivers caught offering illegal ride-hailing services without a valid Public Service Vehicle (PSV) Licence face severe penalties, including fines of up to $3,000, imprisonment for up to six months, or both. These measures are in place to deter unlicensed operators and protect passengers from potential harm. Illegal ride-hailing services oft...